Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Not an emergency, just a "pre-emergency"

View of Providencia from my 13th story apartment last winter. You can barely see the snow-capped Andes in the distance.

In Santiago, the air quality is notoriously bad. The city is nestled between the Andes Mountains and the Coastal Range, which means it sits down in a hole. Look out any upper story window in the winter (and to a lesser extent during the summer too) and you can see the smog. Fly into Santiago during the day and you can see as the plane descends through the smog layer.

Nice image, right?

The majority of pollution (around 70%) is caused by cars and it gets worse in the winter, because as we all learned in elementary school, hot air rises and therefore the smog layer rises as well. I guess this really isn't an improvement, so to speak, but rather a movement of the problem away from our lungs. However, the good thing about winter is that it rains every once in a while and temporarily cleans the air. On days like these I always try to take really deep breaths and of course admire the snow covered Andes that once again come into view.

So what is the Chilean government doing to address this problem? Well, according to these posts, not enough. Chileno points out that as of two years ago, Chile was only measuring PM-10 particles, and that their ranges of "good" (0-100) were considered extremely dangerous in the U.S. Also, apparently Chile doesn't measure for chemicals in the air.

If you take a look at El Mercurio's pollution forecast, it looks like little has changed, at least in terms of what they report to the public. However, Chile's official website This is Chile reported Monday that Santiago is investing money in buying new monitoring equipment. It doesn't state whether this new equipment will measure chemicals or PM-2.5 particles. However, this opinion piece from La Tercera mentions that a new normative to measure PM-2.5 particles has been passed.

The main measure that the government takes to address the pollution problem is vehicular restriction (restricción vehicular in Spanish). On days that the PM-10 particles reach more than 200, the government declares a pre-emergencia ambiental (environmental pre-emergency), and restricts vehicles (depending on the last digit of their license plate) from driving between the hours of 7:30am-10:00pm. For vehicles that don't have a catalytic converters, there is a rotating schedule during the winter for when they can be driven, regardless of pollution levels. Also on pre-emergency days it is not recommendable to do exercise outside.

Is this enough? I don't think so. I'm not sure what the solution is, but one thing that makes me especially angry is when I see people driving in their big car by themselves on they way to work. Carpooling is fun and good for the environment. I think the government (or someone) needs to start measuring the chemicals in the air and create stricter standards for what is considered "good" and "bad" air quality.

I can tell you from personal experience that there are days (like today) that are considered "good" and I walk outside and immediately my eyes start stinging and my throat gets scratchy. My skin has also gotten worse since I've moved here, and while I'm not 100% sure that the air quality is to blame, I bet it has something to do with it. And my problems are trivial when you think about the children who end up in the hospital with lung problems.

11 comments:

dregonzrob said...

Amen sister. How is restricting when people drive and who drives, helping at all?? Chile really needs to get on the bandwagon of PSAs!! They should get on teaching people to take alternate means of transportation and, as you said, highlight the benefits of carpooling. Chile makes me mad sometimes and when it comes to cleaner, healthier living, I want to kick it in the groin (Chile, that is).
I'm also tons drier since moving here. My hair and my skin = gross. And don't even get me started on my cough and throat itch on days like these.
Grrrrr Chile (waving my fists at you!)

Heather said...

Yuck. I can't wait! Reminds me of being in Beijing last summer and wanting to scratch my eyes out.

In China, the response to placing driving restrictions by license plate was countered by people purchasing more cars so they could drive more often! Our poor earth.

Lou said...

It terrifies me to see how little the world is doing regarding environmental issues. I don´t know how much more of this the world can take. Seriously! I hate talking about environmental issues because I get so infuriated and depressed. It just hurts so much to talk about it knowing that there is little the average citizen can do to fix the problem and that in the end, it´s all in the hands of corrupt politicians who only think about the ¨here and now¨. Sigh...

The thing that pisses me off about Santiago regarding their polution problems is that you see so many of those piece of shit big old cars and trucks that emit 10 times more pollution than the average newer cars. Even those old buses are horrible! I say get those things off the streets! Oh man, now you´ve got me going...I must stop before I get red in the face and steam starts coming out of my ears lol!

Kyle said...

It actually seems silly to me that people in Chile drive to work at all, because in the majority of places you can get to and from where you're going in public transportation. Now I'll admit that I'm guilty of taking taxis often -- however, I do feel that's slightly better than a car, as the taxis are already out on the street and would be out with or without me.

Now that I think about it though, I should stop doing that too.

Anonymous said...

Although I agree that the antipoluttion measures are not very effective, they are not limited to "restricción vehicular". There are also limits imposssed on industries located in Santiago. And polution is not mostly cars, but by industries.

In fact, the air improved a lot while we received natural gas from Argentina. But they ceased to supply it after their policies caused their production to drop and teh government resitricted exports. This violated ouiur treaties, by the way, but Chilean governments have traditionaly been reluctant to stand up to Argentina. This caused industries located in Santiago to move back to burning oil instead of the cleaner natural gas.

Hopefully things will improve again when natural gas becomes more available as the Quintero plant becomes fully operational (and the government retightens the polution standards).

Ignacio

Abby said...

dregonzrob: your skin is grosser too? it must be the smog!

Heather: I agree. Our poor earth.

Lou: Yes. Although those old buses are less common now because of Transantiago, they still exist but are painted white and green. They should be taken off the road NOW.

Kyle: I agree! I mean as much as the metro is crowded and nasty at rush hour, in my book it's still better than commuting by yourself.

Ignacio: Thanks for your comment. Where did you find the statistic that factories cause the majority of pollution? I was looking for that, because that's what I originally thought, but only found the statistic that cars were the main cause. I did read an article that said in recent years more cars and increased construction have had more of an impact than previous years.

And you're right, on pre-emergencia days factories are restricted. But,I've heard that many factories are willing to pay a fine rather than stop production on these days.

FuuRe said...

Well, rain is expected tomorrow so everything will be cleaner in the weekend.

And well, you can always take a little trip to the beach, you're just an hour and a half of a great weather and clear skies.

Encontré tu blog googleando info de la noticia de la niña que cayó del piso 11 (en inglés, dunno why i ended here), y me nació escribir un par de lineas :P

Saludos!

Sara said...

I read that Santiago residents are on the road to being diagnosed with all sorts of weird cancers a few years down the road because of all the chemicals in the air. Gross. Breathing in this city hurts because it's toxic! TOXIC. I don't know what the solution is, but what they are doing doesn't seem to be working.

gg2008 said...

There seems to be some issues with what is being reported by the linked bloggers.

The article by C.hileno provides wrong information.

This is what I found through some Google searches:

PM10 counts ug/m3 -- not number of particles.

This is the ICAP definition:
http://www.seremisaludrm.cl/sitio/pag/aire/indexjs3aireglosario.asp#ICAP

So, the ICAP = 100 when there are 150 ug/M3.

Which is equal to the US ePA standard:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ambient_Air_Quality_Standards

The measured gases does include other pollutants like SO2, etc.

You can see real-time measurements of gases and particules here:
http://www.asrm.cl/paginasSegundoNivel/NivelAire.aspx

CD

Abby said...

FuuRe: Thanks for commenting! I'm happy about the rain today too. I'm looking forward to breathing in cleaner air in the near future!

Sara: I can imagine that's true.

gg2008: Thanks for your info. It makes me feel a bit better to know that Chileno's info was wrong (or maybe outdated? He did write those posts 2 and 3 years ago). However, I still think more can be done about the problem. If you just walk outside on almost any day during the winter(well, except today because of the rain) and it's disgusting. And I think the majority of Chileans are not concious of how serious the situation is and the long term health effects it may have.

Maeskizzle said...

I was just kind of barely starting to get nostalgic about moving out of Santiago (and Chile), and then I saw the title to your post and cringed thinking about the nasty air pollution there. Guess I don't really miss Santiago centro that much. Just friends and fam mostly. :(
hope the air quality improves
saludos